The United Nations apologises for the cholera it brought to Haiti
August to December 2016 · span · Haitian
The 2000sDechoukaj1 source
August to December 2016 · Haitianspan
The United Nations apologises for the cholera it brought to Haiti
Six years of denial ended with an apology and a legal position that did not move.
›Read the full entryClose
Cholera had never been recorded in Haiti before United Nations troops introduced it in the autumn of 2010 through defective sanitation at one of their bases. Conservative counts put the dead at ten thousand and the sick at close to a million, about a tenth of the population, and researchers who have followed the epidemic believe the real numbers are several times that. In August 2016, after more than five years of denials, Secretary General Ban Ki-moon acknowledged that the organisation had a role in the outbreak and promised a new response within two months. In December he said that the United Nations apologised to the Haitian people, and set out a plan to eliminate the disease and compensate victims. Alongside the apology the organisation restated its legal immunity from claims by anyone the epidemic had harmed. What forced the shift was an internal report by the special rapporteur Philip Alston, who condemned the cholera policy in terms the institution could not absorb quietly.
Where this comes fromJohnston, J. (2024). Aid state: Elite panic, disaster capitalism, and the battle to control Haiti. St. Martin's Press. pp. 258, 259, 260.
A court cancels the citizenship of a woman born in 1984
Juliana Deguis Pierre asked for an identity card and lost her birth certificate instead.
›Read the full entryClose
Juliana Deguis Pierre was born in the Dominican Republic in 1984. Her parents lived and worked on a sugar plantation and neither had legal residence, and under the law of the time she was issued a birth certificate. In 2008, aged twenty four, she went to an office to request her cedula, the national identity card. The staff refused it and cancelled her birth certificate on the ground that both her parents carried Haitian surnames. In 2013 the new Constitutional Court took her appeal as one of its first cases and ruled that she had never been entitled to citizenship at all, that everyone in the same position should lose theirs, and that the records of people registered as Dominican between 1929 and 2007 should be audited and moved into the register for foreigners. The court also ordered the government to produce a plan within ninety days for migrants without papers.
Juliana Deguis PierreDominican Republic
Where this comes fromSource not recorded for this entry.
The peaceful Arawak and the cannibal Carib are inventions
Two tidy island peoples, one gentle and one savage, come out of novels rather than the ground.
›Read the full entryClose
Anyone taught anything about the Caribbean before Columbus was probably taught two peoples: the gentle Arawak, who were wiped out, and the fierce Carib, who ate them. James Michener sold the pair to millions of readers and early archaeology supplied the labels. William Keegan and Corinne Hofman argue that the division is a filing system rather than a finding. The islands held enormous variety in language, settlement, craft and politics, and communities built shifting alliances across water in ways a two tribe scheme cannot hold. The excavated record shows no series of clean displacements in which one people replaces another. It shows a kaleidoscope, their word, of movement and mixture, with goods, techniques, styles and people crossing between the islands and to and from the mainland for thousands of years. This matters for Haiti. The island that became Saint-Domingue is usually granted a single indigenous population that vanished, which is an easier story to tell than the one the sites support.
James MichenerCaribbeanHispaniola
Where this comes fromSource not recorded for this entry.
One of fifteen world history textbooks still omits the revolution
Johnson's own survey finds coverage growing, and the authorship badly skewed.
›Read the full entryClose
Johnson assembled fifteen printed world history textbooks with editions published across a five year window, gathering the information through scholars on social media. One contained no mention of the Haitian Revolution at all, three gave it less than a page, and four gave it four pages or more, which she reads as an overall increase in space since the earlier survey. Her more pointed finding concerns who writes these books. Only three had authors specialising in any aspect of Latin American history and only five had authors whose research concentrates on African history, while the largest group of contributors specialised in Asian history. She notes that many authors came from elite institutions and that several were late in their careers or had died since a first edition, and argues that early career scholars at teaching-focused institutions are largely absent.
Erica JohnsonUnited States
Where this comes fromSource not recorded for this entry.